Nestled between the stunning waters of Lake Michigan and Green Bay, Door County is celebrated for its beautiful landscapes and quaint towns. But it is the diverse dining scene that makes Door County truly special. While popular restaurants often get the spotlight, a number of lesser-known eateries deserve your attention. Join us as we explore the best-kept secret restaurants in Door County, where exceptional food meets a cozy atmosphere. Whether you are a local resident or a visitor, these spots promise to please your palate.
The Must-Try: The Blue Horse Bistro
Tucked away in Egg Harbor, The Blue Horse Bistro is a delightful find that feels like a well-guarded secret. With a strong focus on farm-to-table dining, this bistro offers a seasonal menu that showcases the freshest ingredients from the region. The laid-back yet sophisticated ambiance is perfect for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner.
Their signature dish, the Blue Horse Salad, features mixed greens topped with locally-sourced goat cheese, walnuts, and a homemade vinaigrette. Pair it with a unique cocktail like the Lavender Lemonade, a refreshing blend that encapsulates the essence of summer. Consider visiting during their happy hour when small plates are offered at a 20% discount, making it a great time to sample several dishes.
Rustic Charm: The Waterfront Restaurant
Head over to The Waterfront Restaurant in Sister Bay for a dining experience that comes with picturesque views. As the name suggests, this gem is located right on the water, providing a stunning backdrop for sunset dining.
The Waterfront is renowned for its fresh fish dishes, in particular, the Pan-Seared Walleye, which is locally caught and perfectly seasoned. The outdoor patio allows you to enjoy your meal while soaking in the natural beauty that surrounds you. Don’t miss their homemade key lime pie for dessert; in fact, a survey of patrons revealed that over 85% consider it the best dessert in Door County.
Italian Flavors: Alexander's
If you're in the mood for Italian cuisine, make your way to Alexander's in Fish Creek. This family-owned restaurant has become famous for its brown butter gnocchi and house-made pasta, crafted using traditional recipes passed down through generations.
The warm and inviting atmosphere, accented by rustic decor and cozy seating, creates a perfect setting for family dinners or gatherings with friends. Wine lovers will appreciate the carefully curated selections, making it easy to find the perfect pairing for your meal.
The Sweet Spot: Door County Creamery
After savoring the savory dishes of Door County, treat yourself to something sweet at Door County Creamery in Egg Harbor. This charming shop specializes in artisan cheeses but is equally famous for its incredible gelato and desserts.
Their gelato, crafted from local ingredients, is a refreshing must-try in the summer. Flavors like Raspberry Chocolate Chip and Sea Salt Caramel frequently receive rave reviews and are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Enjoy your treat on the patio amidst the greenery, providing a delightful way to relax after a day of exploration.
Cozy and Casual: The Fireside Restaurant
Located right in the heart of Fish Creek, The Fireside Restaurant is perfect for those looking for a comfortable dining experience. Known for providing "comfort food with a twist," their menu includes indulgent items like decadent mac and cheese and mouthwatering burgers made from 100% locally-sourced beef.
The cozy atmosphere is enhanced by a rustic fireplace, making it an inviting spot during colder months. This restaurant is a favorite gathering place among locals, offering a traditional gathering experience paired with contemporary flair.
Breathtaking Views: The Hilltop
For those seeking a dining experience with both delicious food and breathtaking views, The Hilltop in Fish Creek is a must-visit. Sitting atop a hillside, the restaurant offers stunning panoramic views, especially beautiful at sunset.
Their menu features an array of grilled entrees and creative sides, with the Brandy-glazed Carrots standing out as a unique offering. They also provide a diverse selection of craft beers that are perfect for pairing with any meal. Enjoying a meal here while watching the sun dip below the horizon is simply unforgettable.
A Little Something Different: Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant
If you're interested in trying something different, visit Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant in Sister Bay. This establishment is famous for its iconic grass-covered roof and authentic Swedish cuisine loved by locals and visitors alike.
Al Johnson’s serves a variety of traditional dishes, such as Swedish pancakes and hearty meatballs. The warm and welcoming atmosphere creates a special dining experience every day. Be sure to stop by for breakfast to enjoy the famous pancakes topped with lingonberries and whipped cream; it's a treat you won’t soon forget.
Discover Door County's Culinary Treasures
Food enthusiasts and outdoor adventurers alike will discover something to love in Door County's remarkable hidden restaurants. From cozy bistros to scenic waterfront dining, the culinary experience here is varied and flavorful. Each of these hidden gems is about more than just the food; they offer a delightful dining atmosphere that captures the spirit of Door County.
So, the next time you visit this charming area, take the time to explore off the beaten path. Experience the exceptional flavors and inviting ambiance of these incredible restaurants. You might just unearth your new favorite dining spot.
Enjoy your culinary journey!
Comments